Chiapas: Presentation of the Report by the UN Special Rapporteur regarding the Right to Food in Chiapas

June 20, 2012

Photo: Sipaz

On 14 June 2012, there was presented in San Cristóbal de Las Casas the Report by the UN Special Rapporteur regarding the Right to Food, a mission that was carried last June, a time during which the Rapporteur met with different civil and social organizations in Chiapas.

The act was presided over by Javier Hernández, representative of the Office of the High Commissioner of the UN for Human Rights in Mexico.  Other participants included Eduardo Benítez, adjunct representative of the FAO (the UN Food and Agriculture Organization), Marina Patricia Jiménez from the State Council on Human Rights (CEDH), and Oscar Torrens, director of the UN Regional Office for Development. From civil society were present on the panel Marcos Arana (CCESC, OBSCUIDES, IBFAN), Michael Chamberlain (INICIA), and Ana Valadez (Otros Mundos).

The participants shared their views regarding the document by the Special Rapporteur, Olivier de Schutter, which presents a summary of the situation in Mexico regarding the right to food.  At the moment of his visit to Mexico, this right did not exist within Mexican law, such that there is a need to construct it within a legal context similar to other conventions and accords. One of the recommendations presented by the Rapporteur was to “strengthen the legislative and institutional context regarding hte approval of a law for the right to food.”  In October of last year, Mexico approved a constitutional reform that recognizes the right to food in the country, thus urging authorities to implement the law so as to make this right a reality for all Mexicans.

In the presentation in San Cristóbal, there was stressed the particularity of Chiapas in these terms, given the high percentage of different indigenous peoples in the state, these being populations who are especially vulnerable to deprivation and lack of access to adequate nutrition.

Among vulnerable sectors was also mentioned women who in general are those who are responsible for the preparation of food, but whose rights are limited due to their lack of right to participate in assemblies and the denial they face for possessing property.  It was then indicated that aid programs such as Oportunidades do not necessarily favor women, instead requiring them to go to meetings if they do not want to lose their right to the program.  Several speakers indicated finally that they have seen in different places how aid programs are exploited by different political candidates for electoral ends.

Beyond this, there was discussed malnutrition among children younger than 5 years of age in Mexico, in addition to the growing issues of obesity and the high extent of diabetes, this being a combination of problems that is increasingly alarming.

For more information (in Spanish):

Informe completo de la Misión a México (Relator Especial de la ONU sobre el derecho a la alimentación, Olivier De Schutter, 2012)

Experto de la ONU saluda reforma constitucional que reconoce el derecho a la alimentación (13 de octubre de 2011)

Propone la ONU a México crear ley sobre el derecho a la alimentación(Proceso, 8 de marzo de 2012)

For more information from SIPAZ (in English):

Chiapas: Visit by Oliver De Shutter, UN Special Rapporteur on Right to Food (21 June 2011)


Chiapas: Visit by Oliver De Shutter, UN Special Rapporteur on Right to Food

June 21, 2011

Oliver De Shutter @ Oaxaca Libre

During the week of official visit to Mexico by the UN Special Rapporteur on the Right to Food, Oliver De Shutter met in Chiapas with campesino groups and NGOs that denounced that in the state there operate economic policies that favor the free market with regard to rural development, as stipulated by the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA).  They affirmed that this has contributed to the fact that the state is no longer the principal producer of maize in the country, instead becoming a state of transit for producing and importing firms, which amounts to a loss of food sovereignty that affects hundreds of thousands of indigenous and campesino families.

The Rapporteur, who also visited the El Pinar Sustainable Rural City, encountered in vivo the denunciations and proposals of the organizations (among them those of maize producers) that accused the State of facilitating the experimental cultivation of transgenic maize in the north of Mexico and the welcoming of the Monsanto corporation via an agreement recently signed between the state government and the foundation Fundar, related to the multinational in Chiapas.  Coffee-workers also declared that the firm AMSA, associated with Nestlé, is promoting a variety of transgenic coffee.

Juan Velasco, from the cooperative Chol Xumulhá, indicated that “the production of maize is basic for self-development and alimentation, but in any case the tendency among the people is commercial agricultural production–coffee, for example–which can constitute an important source of income for campesinos, but does not resolve problems of sustenance.”

Dr. Marcos Arana, from the National Institute on Nutrition and the Center for Training for Campesinos (CCESC), noted that “it would be necessary to undertake an evaluation of the impact of Rural Cities that be external and independent which would investigate the consequences for the people affected.  Chiapas has become a state that expels populations.  It is estimated that in recent years, between 8 and 10% of the population of Chiapas has migrated to the United States, Cancún, and Ciudad Juárez.  This is a symptom of the abandonment in which rural populations find themselves.”  He also announced that more than 80% of the children of Chiapas suffer from nutritional problems such as obesity and malnutrition.

The organizations agreed that food culture is in a process of erosion.  They indicated that in indigenous communities soda and assorted items are cheapter than water and milk, resulting in massive increases in the consumption of such among the indigenous, particularly those who have limited access to the waters of rivers.

Among the proposals that the civil-society organizations presented to the Rapporteur was the importance of prohibiting the cultivation of transgenic maize and instead promoting indigenous, familial, small-scale agriculture, based in traditional knowledge of the management of agrosystems and the incorporation of natural and organic materials.

The efficacy of subsidy programs such as Oportunidades and Procampo was also questioned, given that they do not reach the most remote communities: “It is clear that these programs and others should be designed with human rights as a base, and this is not only an argument: these programs cannot be based in charity but are rather the rights of persons,” concluded the UN functionary.  De Shutter observed that it is clear that the Rural Cities program attends to the consequences of populational dispersal, but not to the causes, such as distribution of land and lack of employment, as indicated by the organizations.  The Special Rapporteur warned that, if present public policies be continued, Mexico will need to import 80% of its food, with campesinos continuing to abandon their lands.

For more information (in Spanish):

Chiapas: Organizaciones se reúnen con relator de la ONU para el derecho a la alimentación, Oaxaca Libre, 16 June 2011

En 30 años, México importará 80% de los alimentos: ONU, Otros Mundos Chiapas, 15 June 2011

Avala relator de la ONU disminución de desnutrición en Chiapas, SDP Noticias, 16 June 2011

Relator de ONU sobre alimentación visita México, El Universal, 12 June 2011

Visitará relator sobre el derecho a alimentación, Cuarto Poder, 13 June 2011